Mystery Manse Update: Deco Duel on Liberty Hill
Monday, October 8, 2007, by Sarah Hromack
Last week we inquired about453 Liberty Street (left) in what we believe to be Liberty Hill, even though it is, technically, situated in Eureka Valley/ Dolores Heights. In fact, the post caused a nice little debate over location, location, location—and, incidentally, inspired our new mini-feature MLS/GPS. (452 Liberty Street; MLS: 5k; GPS: Lat: 37.756963 / Long: -122.431377). While MLS maps do come in handy for starting camp fires identifying neighborhoods, our burning question concerned the actual building itself which, as we noted the first time around, has been under construction since as long as we can remember. Enter kind neighbor/reader Anonymous, who delivered the dirt on this Deco megalith:
the guy has been working on it for the 12 years I've lived down the block. Some like it. I definitely don't. Maybe he thinks it complements the art deco apartments (now condos) on the liberty street stairs nearby. Or probably he just doesn't care. He's been working on the front steps for at least two years now. The guy definitely likes projects.
Twelve years. What devotion! It has come to our attention, however, that 453 Liberty Street has some competition: Just around the corner, at the intersection of Sanchez and Hill Streets, lies another mass of concrete Deco decadence, currently under renovation by Steve Gray Design. Face off: which do we like better, Curbed connoisseurs? And who can tell us more about our second specimen (codename: "polar bear") before the contractors call us back?
· Mystery Manse: 453 Liberty Street, Liberty Hill [Curbed SF]
I know you're new and all, so the distinction between Liberty Hill and Eureka Valley is a nuance, but misspelling Dolores is really going to show your newbie status. Delores is your aunt in Peoria. Dolores is the palm tree lined street in SF.
Bless me father, for in my haste, I failed to thoroughly edit my copy... Sindy and anon anon? Hired! You're the new Curbed SF copy editors-in-residence. We'll be delivering your prizes (polar bears, of course) shortly.
The "Polar Bear" is actually not influenced by Art Deco as much as it is by the Moderne style. The two often get confused, and in fact, the end of the Deco period and the inception of the Moderne style overlap by as much as a decade or more. Art Deco, though, is heavily influenced by stylized references to many past periods, reinterpreted in a very unique way, while Moderne is far more influenced by severe simplicity, often an exaggerated horizontal line, and the idea of movement and speed-- that is why it is often linked to transportation themes and transportation architecture associated with the period.
In addition, I'd like to add that the original house we started with had some very strong Moderne themes that were not quite fulfilled in he original design We elaborated on these existing themes by further emphasizing the horizontal line with the lomg band of glass block on the upper bays, and adding ledges above several winnows. A fresh layer of whitre stucco further emphasized the Moderne period.
The Planning Department was well aware we were proposing to alter a building of some significance to the period, and while it rarely encourages this kind of renovation, the clients and I were given unanimous support by the Planning Commission for our efforts to renovate and add to the structure by elaborating on the home’s existing Moderne theme.
About Curbed SF
From the Golden Gate to The Mission, in San Francisco, it all comes back to our neighborhoods: where we live, where we work, where we eat, and where we play. Covering real estate sales, rental prices, and news-making deals and much more, it's all on Curbed SF. More about Curbed SF...